Vowing to take his mother to perform `Umrah in Ramadan if what he wants to happen occurs, but taking her before his wish is granted

Q 2: I made a vow to take my mother to perform `Umrah (lesser pilgrimage) during Ramadan if a certain event happened. However, I went to `Umrah with her - but not during Ramadan - before the event took place, and I did it with the intention that, if the event did occur, that `Umrah would be in place of the `Umrah in Ramadan. Should I now go with my mother to perform `Umrah once again during Ramadan or is the `Umrah we performed before sufficient to keep my vow? Q 4: I vowed to slaughter a sheep and give it as Sadaqah (voluntary charity) if I passed a specific academic year. Is it permissible to give an equivalent of the cost of a sheep as Sadaqah instead of slaughtering one?


A: You should keep your vow and take your mother to perform `Umrah during Ramadan, and slaughter a sheep and feed the poor. It did not count (Part No. 23; Page No. 286) as a fulfillment of your vow when you took your mother to `Umrah before Ramadan, nor will it count to give the price of a sheep in Sadaqah instead of slaughtering one. It is confirmed that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: Whoever vows to be obedient to Allah must be obedient to Him. May Allah grant us success. May peace and blessings be upon our Prophet Muhammad, his family, and Companions.


Tags: